5 underrated Indianapolis area eateries
We have all seen the lists with the most popular local restaurants and although they are AMAZING, we wanted to shine the spotlight on some of the underrated spots that are putting the Indianapolis area on the culinary map.
Why we love it: Located in Westfield IN, right off the Monon trail and only a stone’s throw from Grand Park, their location couldn’t be more ideal for North-siders. It gives warehouse-chic vibes along with a seasonally rotating menu while keeping cult favorites such as the Chicken & Noodles and Hoosier Hot Plate. They do a phenomenal job highlighting the rich flavors and traditions of American cuisine by incorporating locally sourced meats and vegetables, fresh pasta, and smoked meats. Every Thursday they have live music on the patio where you can unwind with a featured cocktail or local beer. Check them out on Instagram!
Perks: Accepts reservations / Kid-friendly / Outdoor dining
Call (317) 763-1100 or visit 17470 W Wheeler Rd, Westfield, IN 46074
Why we love It: Stationed in the heart of Broad Ripple Village is an awesome BBQ joint serving up authentic Texas-style BBQ in a welcoming family-friendly setting. This joint can compete with the big guns of BBQ with their quality hardwood smoked meats and equally delicious scratch sides. Open for lunch & dinner with a weekend special every Friday & Saturday with a unique brunch special every Sunday. Find them on Instagram!
Perks: Kids eat free on Tuesdays / Multiple outdoor dining options / Convenient on-site parking
Call (317) 744-0025 or visit 6320 Guilford Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Why we love it: Nestled in the Windsor Park neighborhood, in an arthouse cinema, is a hidden gem. It’s no surprise this farm-to-table restaurant is so incredible as Abbi Merriss, James Beard-nominated chef, is leading this all-star cast! Featuring fresh and locally raised meats, this European-inspired menu effortlessly blends the eclectic international flavors with the comforting mainstays of the Midwest. We love that you can dine at The Brasserie without having to purchase a movie ticket, but why not make a night of it by coming for dinner and a movie! Keep up with them on Instagram.
Perks: Accepts reservations / Brunch Saturday & Sunday / Starring leading lady, Abbi Merriss renowned for her work at Bluebeard
Call (317) 800-7099 or visit 1258 Windsor St. Indianapolis, IN
Why we love it: Attention all pizza snobs & casual pie-lovers alike: We have found THE best pizza in Indy! Owners Brian & Alexis are serving up unique international-inspired pizzas baked to perfection with ingredients that are a step above. Don’t get us started on the wings, wing bites, and all the dipping sauces. Let’s not forget the hand-picked single-barrel whiskey selections straight from Kentucky. Seriously, we could go on and on. Peek their pizza on Instagram!
Perks: Kid-friendly / Gluten-free options / Unique bourbon menu
Call (317) 798-2056 or visit 2430 E 146th St, Carmel, IN 46033
Why we love it: Monterey Cuisine serves the freshest seafood, most tender aged beef, and world-class sushi — all created by their award-winning artisan chefs. We love a restaurant that serves not only unforgettable food but also serves up a vibe and Monterey does just that with the gorgeous decor! Pull up a chair on their patio (facing the Monon Trail!) & sip one of Monterey’s craft cocktails, beer, wine, or sake. Follow them on Instagram.
Perks: Accepts reservations / Fresh seafood /Exceptional kid’s menu
Call (317) 853-2280 or visit 110 W Main St Suite 135, Carmel, IN 46032
